Ex-Premier League and FIFA referee gives verdict on trio of controversial VAR decisions in Leeds United's defeat to Arsenal - Yorkshire Post 17/10/22
Former Premier League and FIFA listed referee Dermot Gallagher believes that VAR got all three major decisions correct in Leeds United’s controversial loss to Arsenal at Elland Road on Saturday afternoon.
By Ben McKenna
Bukayo Saka’s thumping first-half finish was enough to
clinch the Gunners their ninth win in 10 league games, while Leeds missed a penalty
and had another spot-kick decision overturned in stoppage time.
Bamford, a half-time replacement for Rodrigo, was central to
Leeds’ inspired second-half display.
He had the ball in the net moments after the restart but it
was ruled out by VAR for his push on Gabriel, and he dragged a penalty wide
after Kavanagh had consulted the pitch-side monitor to judge on William
Saliba’s handball.
Kavanagh awarded Leeds another spot-kick in time added on
after Gabriel had kicked out at Bamford and the Arsenal defender was shown a
straight red card.
But after checking the monitor again, Kavanagh overturned
both decisions, with Bamford shown to have shoved Gabriel first, and the
Brazilian’s red card was changed to yellow.
“I thought it was a foul, when you look at it, it’s hard to
say it is not a foul,” said Gallagher on Sky Sports News of Bamford’s
disallowed goal.
Saliba’s handball was spotted by VAR although some were
questioning why the penalty was awarded after Rasmus Kristensen was offside in
the build-up.
"I think it is handball, not given on the field but
given by VAR. He moves towards the ball, so it is a penalty for me,” added
Gallagher.
"He [Kristensen] is offside, there is no doubt about
that. But it went on too long, the ball goes back and gets recycled, it takes
too long so they don’t go back that far.
"There has to be a point where you have to reset.”
Gallagher felt it was the right decision to overturn the red
card to Gabriel, claiming the defender’s kick at Bamford was “reckless” but not
violent conduct.
He said: "I think it is a really interesting incident.
The referee doesn’t give anything but goes over to his assistant, who says to
him that Gabriel has kicked out.
"It is quite clearly a foul [from Bamford], we see the
kick [from Gabriel] – it is petulant, it is unsporting but it is not violent. I
think it is reckless at worst. The first foul is by Bamford.
"I think ultimately the right decision has arisen from
that.”
